Replies and Record Reply Outcome

Replies and Record Reply Outcome

A reply is the point of a journey. The moment a prospect writes back, the automated emails stop, and the conversation becomes yours. Codex reads each reply once, decides what kind of message it is, and, for a real reply, asks you to say what it means. This lesson covers both halves.

How Codex reads a reply

When the mailbox reading files a message from a prospect in a journey, Codex sorts it into one of four kinds:

Kind What Codex does
An automatic reply or a delivery report Marks it automated and changes nothing else. A delivery report is handled as a bounce
An out-of-office reply Marks it automated, and moves the next automated email to the opening of the window on or after the return date in the message. With no date, the email waits seven business days
A removal request only (“unsubscribe”, “remove me”, “stop”, or “opt out”) Suppresses the address and ends the journey, with no task
Any other message A human reply. The journey becomes Replied, which stops its automated emails, and you receive one task of the type Follow Up to review the reply

A message that arrived before the journey was created is ignored.

What you see

A human reply shows in three places: the person’s timeline as Email Received, the Replies tab of your Work Queue as a review task, and the Replied tab of Sales → Prospect Journeys. Read the reply in Outlook, answer it from Outlook or the Email window as you normally would, then record what it means.

Record Reply Outcome

On the journey, select Record Reply Outcome. The window reads “Record the outcome of the reply” and “Read the reply, then say what it means. The journey and the company follow from your answer.” Choose one of six outcomes:

Outcome When to use it What happens
Positive The prospect is interested The journey completes, and automated email to the other contacts at the company pauses
Negative This person is not interested The journey is cancelled, and the person goes to Nurture or is Disqualified, as you choose under Where does the person go?
Negative for the Whole Company Nobody at the company is interested Every open journey at the company is cancelled, and the company is paused
Neutral No decision yet, for example “ask me next quarter” The journey picks up again on its schedule
Unsubscribe Request The prospect asked to be removed The address is suppressed, and the journey ends
Wrong Person You reached the wrong contact The journey ends with your notes, and the person is left as they are

The first decision on a reply stands. A reply never moves the lifecycle stage by itself; a booked meeting or an opportunity does that.

Resume instead

A journey in Replied can also be resumed with Resume, which leaves the follow-up task open. Use it when the reply was a short acknowledgement, such as “Thanks, I will read this later”, and you want the journey to continue as planned. Neutral does the same and also answers the review task, so prefer Neutral when you have read the reply and decided.

Worked examples

“Can you send me a time next week?” Book the meeting from Outlook, then record Positive. The journey completes, and the other contacts at the company stop receiving automated email while you work the deal. Open an opportunity from here and keep its Next Commitment current.

“We signed a three-year contract with another provider in June.” Record Negative for the Whole Company if the decision covers everyone, and add a note with the renewal date so a colleague can revisit it.

“I moved to a new role; please contact Alex Chen instead.” Record Wrong Person with Alex’s name in the notes, then create or find Alex and enroll them separately.

“Please stop emailing me.” Record Unsubscribe Request. The address is suppressed and the journey ends. If the prospect asked not to be contacted at all, also set Do Not Contact.

What you should remember

  • A human reply moves the journey to Replied, stops its automated emails, and gives you a Follow Up review task.
  • Out-of-office replies move the next email to the return date, or seven business days without one.
  • A removal-only reply suppresses the address and ends the journey with no task.
  • Record Reply Outcome offers six outcomes, and the first one recorded stands.
  • Positive completes the journey and pauses the other contacts at the company.

The next lesson covers the other ways a journey stops: pauses, holds, ends, and stops.